WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.160 --> 00:00:00.641
Why?

2
00:00:01.962 --> 00:00:02.522
Why?

3
00:00:03.423 --> 00:00:14.534
Policymakers believe that vulnerable households have a few thousand euros in their pocket to invest and then reclaim the price of their new heat pump.

4
00:00:14.874 --> 00:00:15.214
Like,

5
00:00:15.835 --> 00:00:16.235
why?

6
00:00:16.836 --> 00:00:18.437
And if they have it in their pocket,

7
00:00:18.537 --> 00:00:19.919
why do they need a subsidy?

8
00:00:20.980 --> 00:00:23.662
So it's just incredibly...

9
00:00:24.743 --> 00:00:25.003
Like,

10
00:00:25.144 --> 00:00:25.464
I think...

11
00:00:26.024 --> 00:00:31.887
Often policymakers still believe that we only need to incentivize these investments,

12
00:00:31.927 --> 00:00:33.928
so we have a little bit of money,

13
00:00:34.048 --> 00:00:40.391
so people would do it more willingly than without the support.

14
00:00:44.053 --> 00:00:50.156
The EU's energy transition includes explicit commitment to prioritize vulnerable households.

15
00:00:50.376 --> 00:00:52.377
The Energy Performance of Building Directive,

16
00:00:52.437 --> 00:00:53.037
for instance,

17
00:00:53.078 --> 00:00:57.320
requires that financial incentives target energy poverty affected households.

18
00:00:57.820 --> 00:01:07.505
The Energy Efficiency Directive requires member states to make the best possible use of public funding for investment supporting low-income and vulnerable consumers.

19
00:01:07.886 --> 00:01:09.266
There are legal obligations.

20
00:01:10.127 --> 00:01:10.547
And yet,

21
00:01:10.827 --> 00:01:16.030
the negotiations are currently underway on the Multi-Annual Financial Framework,

22
00:01:16.570 --> 00:01:17.351
or MFF,

23
00:01:17.531 --> 00:01:19.112
for 2028-20.

24
00:01:19.544 --> 00:01:23.265
34 contain no earmarking for vulnerable households.

25
00:01:23.845 --> 00:01:32.528
Committees in the European Parliament have been moving to remove even the weakest just transition reference that exists in the Commission's proposal.

26
00:01:33.348 --> 00:01:37.869
Evidence from cohesion funding and national renovation programs shows that public money,

27
00:01:38.189 --> 00:01:40.510
absent targeting requirements,

28
00:01:41.030 --> 00:01:45.871
flows overwhelmingly to those with the financial capacity to co-invest.

29
00:01:46.511 --> 00:01:48.652
And as Sophia Bayomi has been the past...

30
00:01:48.972 --> 00:01:58.076
several years mapping exactly this gap between what EU law says should happen and what budget architecture is designed to deliver.

31
00:01:58.736 --> 00:02:04.259
Her doctoral research examined the situation of vulnerable firewood-dependent households in Hungary,

32
00:02:04.859 --> 00:02:15.643
where EU transition policies encounter both a severe energy vulnerability profile and a national government structurally resistant to redistributive Vinny G.

33
00:02:15.683 --> 00:02:16.004
Polisi.

34
00:02:17.300 --> 00:02:17.900
At FANSA,

35
00:02:18.141 --> 00:02:22.263
the European Federation of National Organizations Working with the Homeless,

36
00:02:22.843 --> 00:02:27.546
she has extended that analysis to the EU's institutions themselves,

37
00:02:27.986 --> 00:02:33.169
tracing the line between legislative principle and funding reality across many instruments,

38
00:02:33.209 --> 00:02:34.690
including the EPPD,

39
00:02:35.190 --> 00:02:35.590
ETS2,

40
00:02:35.970 --> 00:02:37.911
the Social Climate Fund and the MFF.

41
00:02:38.432 --> 00:02:39.392
So in this episode,

42
00:02:39.472 --> 00:02:45.836
we will reflect on what happens when the legal framework says one thing and the budget says another.

43
00:02:46.504 --> 00:02:51.468
what determines which one wins and who bears the cost of that gap.

44
00:02:53.190 --> 00:02:54.051
I'm Marine Cornelis.

45
00:02:54.251 --> 00:02:55.191
Welcome to Energetic.

46
00:02:55.452 --> 00:02:55.632
Anna,

47
00:02:55.832 --> 00:02:56.533
welcome to the show.

48
00:02:57.393 --> 00:02:57.894
Welcome,

49
00:02:58.534 --> 00:02:59.055
everybody,

50
00:02:59.275 --> 00:03:03.118
and thanks for this opportunity and for the introduction.

51
00:03:04.179 --> 00:03:04.680
Of course,

52
00:03:04.720 --> 00:03:04.900
Anna.

53
00:03:05.080 --> 00:03:05.760
Thank you so much,

54
00:03:05.780 --> 00:03:05.921
Anna.

55
00:03:06.041 --> 00:03:09.784
So you have a background in social policy and urban planning.

56
00:03:10.492 --> 00:03:13.354
And you have moved between municipal government,

57
00:03:13.434 --> 00:03:14.755
parliamentary offices,

58
00:03:14.815 --> 00:03:15.896
research institutions,

59
00:03:15.956 --> 00:03:22.041
civil society and housing NGOs in Hungary and also in Italy before arriving at

60
00:03:22.381 --> 00:03:23.382
EU level advocacy.

61
00:03:24.322 --> 00:03:26.704
That's quite an unusual path to energy policy.

62
00:03:26.944 --> 00:03:32.148
So what's your understanding of energy poverty before you were working on it professionally?

63
00:03:34.190 --> 00:03:37.072
So already when I was a teenager.

64
00:03:37.432 --> 00:03:43.175
I spent time in Hungary in one of the poorest regions in a rural

65
00:03:44.116 --> 00:03:45.156
Roma settlement.

66
00:03:45.477 --> 00:03:47.398
And during our visits,

67
00:03:47.778 --> 00:03:59.945
I discovered the low quality housing stock in which this community was living and the use of firewood and the really heavy indoor air,

68
00:04:00.445 --> 00:04:02.686
which made children sick.

69
00:04:02.966 --> 00:04:04.227
and it stuck with me.

70
00:04:06.232 --> 00:04:09.514
Within my university studies,

71
00:04:09.734 --> 00:04:12.016
I got interested in urban studies,

72
00:04:12.556 --> 00:04:13.537
housing policy,

73
00:04:14.418 --> 00:04:16.699
and putting all this together,

74
00:04:17.019 --> 00:04:23.123
I ended up working on first segregation problems in post-industrial cities.

75
00:04:23.204 --> 00:04:24.885
But then during my master thesis,

76
00:04:24.925 --> 00:04:32.170
I already wrote my thesis on the energy efficient renovation of social housing stock,

77
00:04:32.370 --> 00:04:35.552
which is very low quality as well in Hungary.

78
00:04:35.972 --> 00:04:43.477
And that's where I started to explore the EU energy framework and all the energy efficiency targets.

79
00:04:43.478 --> 00:04:52.663
And I was wondering why these targets are not translated into opportunities to improve the housing stock of the most vulnerable people.

80
00:04:53.304 --> 00:04:53.684
And then...

81
00:04:54.785 --> 00:04:56.486
Combining my interest,

82
00:04:56.626 --> 00:05:02.668
I worked in an urban planning department at the municipality of Peterpest,

83
00:05:03.148 --> 00:05:07.270
then started to work on energy poverty in the European Parliament as a trainee.

84
00:05:07.830 --> 00:05:11.492
And I kept my interest to energy poverty.

85
00:05:12.052 --> 00:05:21.596
And I tried to develop my professional work along that with my PhD and then my work at Fianza.

86
00:05:23.058 --> 00:05:23.277
Yeah,

87
00:05:23.317 --> 00:05:23.657
and...

88
00:05:24.038 --> 00:05:24.517
When we met,

89
00:05:24.577 --> 00:05:26.199
you were working on your PhD,

90
00:05:26.418 --> 00:05:29.259
which examined vulnerable ferrywood users in Hungary.

91
00:05:30.800 --> 00:05:35.221
They fly totally under the radar in your policymaking.

92
00:05:35.380 --> 00:05:40.983
You very often are the only person raising their hand and saying,

93
00:05:41.163 --> 00:05:41.423
look,

94
00:05:41.803 --> 00:05:44.824
the energy transition is not completed everywhere.

95
00:05:45.644 --> 00:05:49.245
We still have people who burn solid fuels,

96
00:05:49.305 --> 00:05:50.904
including their trash,

97
00:05:50.964 --> 00:05:53.206
in order to heat in the winter.

98
00:05:54.109 --> 00:05:56.330
What do these households,

99
00:05:56.350 --> 00:06:00.371
because you're still working and are very often very close to them,

100
00:06:00.431 --> 00:06:08.993
so what do these households tell you about the energy transition that this kind of official statistics and policy document is missing?

101
00:06:11.214 --> 00:06:22.637
So the example of solid fuel users is highly relevant to illustrate how often the energy transition overlooks the most vulnerable ones.

102
00:06:23.581 --> 00:06:24.442
For example,

103
00:06:24.882 --> 00:06:29.886
the price of firewood is not monitored officially at an EU level,

104
00:06:30.506 --> 00:06:33.929
while electricity and gas prices are.

105
00:06:34.049 --> 00:06:36.311
And when a crisis hits in,

106
00:06:37.171 --> 00:06:47.539
immediately the Commission responds to the crisis by better or worse measures to mitigate the price impact of the crisis.

107
00:06:47.939 --> 00:06:49.741
But firewood users are always...

108
00:06:50.633 --> 00:06:54.437
forgotten because they are simply not appearing in the statistics.

109
00:06:55.538 --> 00:06:56.940
While in Hungary,

110
00:06:58.141 --> 00:07:02.986
firewood price increased in 15 years threefold,

111
00:07:03.547 --> 00:07:10.494
while the gas price only got 1.4 times higher.

112
00:07:11.615 --> 00:07:13.417
And we have

113
00:07:13.777 --> 00:07:18.179
European measures to protect electricity consumers and gas consumers,

114
00:07:18.300 --> 00:07:22.822
but there is no protection framework for solid fuel users,

115
00:07:22.882 --> 00:07:24.623
including firewood users,

116
00:07:25.383 --> 00:07:29.886
despite the fact that across Central and Eastern Europe,

117
00:07:30.446 --> 00:07:31.367
in many countries,

118
00:07:31.407 --> 00:07:39.751
the majority of households in poverty who are not connected to district heating are dependent on solid fuel,

119
00:07:40.131 --> 00:07:41.432
firewood especially.

120
00:07:42.453 --> 00:07:42.933
We got...

121
00:07:43.034 --> 00:07:43.154
to

122
00:07:43.614 --> 00:07:50.579
80% in the Baltic countries and still around 40%

123
00:07:50.719 --> 00:07:51.320
in Hungary,

124
00:07:51.560 --> 00:07:53.303
so among the poorest households.

125
00:07:53.982 --> 00:07:55.724
And this is a really large group.

126
00:07:56.424 --> 00:07:57.606
And on the other hand,

127
00:07:58.386 --> 00:08:03.851
the EU is really proud of the increasing use of renewable energy sources.

128
00:08:04.651 --> 00:08:06.654
And in the heating sector,

129
00:08:07.573 --> 00:08:11.877
it is overwhelmingly reached by solid...

130
00:08:12.058 --> 00:08:13.017
BFUS,

131
00:08:13.717 --> 00:08:17.358
partly by district heating in the Nordic countries,

132
00:08:17.1000 --> 00:08:25.681
but also very importantly by the firewood burned in these poorly insulated homes,

133
00:08:26.041 --> 00:08:29.042
creating indoor and outdoor pollution,

134
00:08:29.442 --> 00:08:40.745
which is then mentioned in countries that are being also punished by the European Union because of air pollution issues caused by firewood burning.

135
00:08:41.026 --> 00:08:52.093
which is then on the other hand is motivated because the renewable energy targets are mandatory and the energy efficiency targets are not.

136
00:08:52.633 --> 00:08:53.173
Therefore,

137
00:08:53.493 --> 00:08:58.976
member states are incentivized almost to keep burning firewood,

138
00:08:59.297 --> 00:09:07.822
while not that much to reduce significantly the energy need of households and consequently the use of firewood.

139
00:09:09.994 --> 00:09:10.855
That's so crazy.

140
00:09:11.075 --> 00:09:20.338
That's just so schizophrenic and totally embodying this challenge that the EU and EU countries and at the end of the day,

141
00:09:20.438 --> 00:09:20.558
the

142
00:09:21.298 --> 00:09:22.197
EU people,

143
00:09:23.418 --> 00:09:26.340
people living in Europe are between a rock and a hard place,

144
00:09:26.399 --> 00:09:26.660
right?

145
00:09:26.760 --> 00:09:33.282
And with the recent energy price crisis and caused...

146
00:09:33.401 --> 00:09:36.303
by the Israel and

147
00:09:36.803 --> 00:09:39.284
US war in Iran and the bloc of farmers,

148
00:09:39.885 --> 00:09:43.786
is the response of the EU also focused very much on energy,

149
00:09:44.587 --> 00:09:47.088
like electricity and gas prices again,

150
00:09:47.168 --> 00:09:48.769
and not enough on solid fuel?

151
00:09:50.137 --> 00:09:50.477
Yes,

152
00:09:50.778 --> 00:09:51.818
it's again the same.

153
00:09:52.058 --> 00:09:59.483
The problem of solid fuel users is not at all appearing in the crisis response documents.

154
00:10:00.044 --> 00:10:03.686
And while there are good elements in the crisis response,

155
00:10:03.746 --> 00:10:10.551
like asking member states to protect vulnerable households,

156
00:10:11.011 --> 00:10:16.715
to work on not to disconnect households from energy supply,

157
00:10:17.415 --> 00:10:19.537
and also in general to reuse.

158
00:10:19.961 --> 00:10:20.722
for example,

159
00:10:20.982 --> 00:10:22.303
energy taxations.

160
00:10:22.723 --> 00:10:25.285
But often these measures,

161
00:10:25.385 --> 00:10:27.246
while are well-intended,

162
00:10:27.306 --> 00:10:31.510
and they at the end aim to reduce energy prices for all,

163
00:10:31.790 --> 00:10:32.450
on the one hand,

164
00:10:32.490 --> 00:10:39.455
they forget to intervene on the energy price of the fuel used by the most vulnerable ones,

165
00:10:40.216 --> 00:10:44.779
which is always indirectly impacted by price increases.

166
00:10:45.960 --> 00:10:47.121
hang it like it's

167
00:10:47.761 --> 00:10:52.663
Not every country has good data on the cost of different fuels,

168
00:10:52.763 --> 00:10:54.823
but Hungary fortunately has.

169
00:10:55.283 --> 00:11:01.365
So we can always see in the charts that when gas prices increase,

170
00:11:02.566 --> 00:11:04.366
gas use decrease,

171
00:11:04.566 --> 00:11:07.527
firewood use increase,

172
00:11:07.667 --> 00:11:10.488
and that pushes up the firewood price.

173
00:11:11.088 --> 00:11:13.509
and in the latest energy crisis.

174
00:11:14.289 --> 00:11:21.172
Firewood prices were increasing much radically than gas or electricity prices.

175
00:11:21.332 --> 00:11:26.734
It's complicated in Hungary because we have regulated electricity and gas prices,

176
00:11:26.814 --> 00:11:29.035
but firewood prices are not regulated.

177
00:11:29.956 --> 00:11:34.437
So this is always overflowing to the firewood prices.

178
00:11:34.818 --> 00:11:38.879
And what I also wanted to say related to the generic measures,

179
00:11:38.959 --> 00:11:42.501
that if we are concentrating on bringing down...

180
00:11:43.385 --> 00:11:44.025
For example,

181
00:11:44.105 --> 00:11:47.986
electricity prices by tax reductions,

182
00:11:48.066 --> 00:11:48.846
for example,

183
00:11:48.907 --> 00:11:52.007
what is really a favorite tool of the commission.

184
00:11:52.708 --> 00:12:01.970
The distributional impact will be again benefiting the affluent groups who have higher consumption.

185
00:12:02.470 --> 00:12:03.190
And for them,

186
00:12:03.191 --> 00:12:03.991
a 10%

187
00:12:04.091 --> 00:12:12.533
reduction will generate significantly more savings compared to the smaller consuming vulnerable.

188
00:12:12.873 --> 00:12:17.596
households that have less electricity consumption.

189
00:12:19.477 --> 00:12:20.077
That's interesting.

190
00:12:20.117 --> 00:12:29.122
And I think there is also a very important seasonal element really showcasing the vulnerability of the firewood users.

191
00:12:29.182 --> 00:12:29.542
As you know,

192
00:12:29.943 --> 00:12:34.125
I've worked quite and I'm still working quite extensively on summer energy poverty,

193
00:12:34.225 --> 00:12:35.065
summer resilience,

194
00:12:35.606 --> 00:12:40.148
the fact that heat waves are harder and harder on us,

195
00:12:40.208 --> 00:12:40.989
on our lives.

196
00:12:41.069 --> 00:12:41.229
and

197
00:12:42.277 --> 00:12:42.958
And actually,

198
00:12:42.978 --> 00:12:43.758
for the record,

199
00:12:44.879 --> 00:12:50.382
I remember very vividly the summer of 2007 being in Budapest and facing.

200
00:12:50.822 --> 00:12:52.844
I was living in Budapest at the time and

201
00:12:53.344 --> 00:12:56.346
I faced so many blackouts because of the heat.

202
00:12:57.126 --> 00:13:03.270
And that's completely clear that there is no solution.

203
00:13:03.910 --> 00:13:08.593
There is not even a thought or afterthought for the people who heat themselves with solid.

204
00:13:09.357 --> 00:13:14.540
because they can't afford any cooling system at all anyway.

205
00:13:14.600 --> 00:13:23.345
So they are facing a double hardship for this use of solid fuel.

206
00:13:24.605 --> 00:13:24.946
Yes,

207
00:13:25.126 --> 00:13:25.766
exactly.

208
00:13:26.947 --> 00:13:32.830
Often these solid fuel stoves are found in dwellings,

209
00:13:33.090 --> 00:13:36.052
which are anyway in quite a bad shape,

210
00:13:36.212 --> 00:13:38.453
including their electric

211
00:13:38.693 --> 00:13:39.294
wiring,

212
00:13:39.834 --> 00:13:43.237
which is already sometimes dangerous.

213
00:13:44.538 --> 00:13:49.823
Once I've been in a village in this region that I already mentioned,

214
00:13:50.303 --> 00:13:52.425
and we were staying in this village house.

215
00:13:52.865 --> 00:13:55.167
And every time when I tried to open the fridge,

216
00:13:55.548 --> 00:14:02.774
I got a little bit of electric shock of the quality of the electric wiring.

217
00:14:02.854 --> 00:14:06.237
And I think it's not an individual issue.

218
00:14:06.577 --> 00:14:08.398
We have statistics that over

219
00:14:09.278 --> 00:14:15.400
100 million electric installations in Europe are outdated.

220
00:14:16.060 --> 00:14:23.482
So we already need to start with that before installing additional electric installations like an air conditioner.

221
00:14:24.582 --> 00:14:26.083
We need to fix that.

222
00:14:26.983 --> 00:14:29.283
And also,

223
00:14:31.044 --> 00:14:34.545
I was surprised about the share of solid fuel.

224
00:14:34.745 --> 00:14:36.226
cooking in Europe.

225
00:14:36.306 --> 00:14:36.426
Yeah.

226
00:14:36.466 --> 00:14:38.147
Which is always...

227
00:14:38.268 --> 00:14:39.328
How much is it?

228
00:14:39.329 --> 00:14:39.548
Well,

229
00:14:39.669 --> 00:14:40.929
at a European average,

230
00:14:41.029 --> 00:14:42.030
it's very little,

231
00:14:42.851 --> 00:14:43.771
but it's

232
00:14:44.512 --> 00:14:45.493
1 or 2%

233
00:14:45.494 --> 00:14:45.813
maybe.

234
00:14:46.413 --> 00:14:48.075
But in some countries like Greece,

235
00:14:48.095 --> 00:14:50.836
it can go up to 15%.

236
00:14:50.957 --> 00:14:51.257
Wow.

237
00:14:52.098 --> 00:14:57.020
And if you imagine that you are cooking with solid fuels also in the summer,

238
00:14:57.900 --> 00:15:02.662
then in the winter it's really convenient because while you are heating your kitchen,

239
00:15:02.702 --> 00:15:03.823
you can also cook.

240
00:15:04.283 --> 00:15:05.243
But in the summer,

241
00:15:06.364 --> 00:15:10.386
you have excess heat because of your heating method.

242
00:15:10.586 --> 00:15:11.706
And yeah,

243
00:15:11.806 --> 00:15:14.747
sometimes it is used interchangeably.

244
00:15:14.968 --> 00:15:19.529
They might have a gas fuel stove as well.

245
00:15:19.890 --> 00:15:20.510
um

246
00:15:22.431 --> 00:15:22.891
Yeah,

247
00:15:22.892 --> 00:15:30.037
and there's nothing glamorous in using only fire and barbecue for your cooking,

248
00:15:30.117 --> 00:15:30.377
right?

249
00:15:30.437 --> 00:15:37.322
So it's also one of the things that make this kind of statistics totally invisible.

250
00:15:38.183 --> 00:15:38.643
Yes,

251
00:15:39.584 --> 00:15:40.564
and also in the

252
00:15:41.345 --> 00:15:43.487
Central Eastern European region,

253
00:15:43.687 --> 00:15:47.549
while it is not related to solid fuels,

254
00:15:47.890 --> 00:15:48.070
but

255
00:15:48.310 --> 00:15:50.851
I guess it's a problem across entire Europe,

256
00:15:50.991 --> 00:16:00.975
but we also have high-rise multi-apartment buildings built during socialism without any insulation from concrete blocks,

257
00:16:01.135 --> 00:16:05.957
and these can also dramatically overheat during summer.

258
00:16:06.637 --> 00:16:15.521
And in the delay of deployment of insulation and solar electricity,

259
00:16:16.261 --> 00:16:17.022
these house,

260
00:16:17.402 --> 00:16:17.642
these...

261
00:16:19.483 --> 00:16:22.024
buildings get hotter and hotter during summer.

262
00:16:22.144 --> 00:16:23.545
They don't have any shading.

263
00:16:24.185 --> 00:16:27.827
And because of the characteristics of the building material,

264
00:16:27.907 --> 00:16:34.950
they really collect all the heat during the day and then they radiate the heat during the night.

265
00:16:35.430 --> 00:16:43.154
And I am living in such an apartment and I'm trying to convince the local representative at the municipality See?

266
00:16:43.554 --> 00:16:44.674
The building manager,

267
00:16:44.834 --> 00:16:47.555
we've been writing with the local NGO letters,

268
00:16:48.415 --> 00:16:59.058
raising attention that it can also be deadly for elderly people to stay in such hot apartments if they have health conditions.

269
00:17:01.759 --> 00:17:04.880
But the renovation of these buildings are moving really,

270
00:17:04.980 --> 00:17:05.720
really slow.

271
00:17:06.540 --> 00:17:08.781
And even when they get renovated,

272
00:17:08.821 --> 00:17:12.562
they are not necessarily paying attention to you

273
00:17:12.802 --> 00:17:14.264
additional issues.

274
00:17:14.484 --> 00:17:16.126
They put the insulation on,

275
00:17:16.426 --> 00:17:17.747
maybe some solar panels,

276
00:17:17.807 --> 00:17:21.551
but they are not tackling the passive cooling,

277
00:17:22.653 --> 00:17:35.186
necessarily the indoor air circulation or outdoor shading solutions that would protect this.

278
00:17:35.486 --> 00:17:36.206
Yeah,

279
00:17:36.207 --> 00:17:37.387
and that's very narrow.

280
00:17:37.447 --> 00:17:43.128
And that's overall one of these issues that you have like funding for one thing.

281
00:17:43.708 --> 00:17:45.029
And so you look into one thing,

282
00:17:45.129 --> 00:17:46.909
but you don't look at the bigger picture.

283
00:17:47.549 --> 00:17:55.452
When sometimes you would need to have a more comprehensive solution to make a difference in the true difference in the life of people.

284
00:17:56.252 --> 00:18:00.893
Because there are also proofs that sometimes if you insulate in a certain way,

285
00:18:00.953 --> 00:18:04.154
you can really make the indoor environment much better.

286
00:18:04.234 --> 00:18:20.544
warmer also in the summer so that's uh that creates like this kind of yeah trap uh for for heat like a greenhouse so that's uh indeed um yeah very very challenging but one of the things you've been working on is the eu funding and

287
00:18:20.584 --> 00:18:30.330
you've been saying that uh there is a lack of earmarking of eu funds and so as a result the eu funds

288
00:18:30.530 --> 00:18:33.892
flow to households who could have financed the transition themselves,

289
00:18:33.932 --> 00:18:36.414
at least in a big portion of it.

290
00:18:37.215 --> 00:18:42.599
And you have pointed to very concrete evidence from cohesion funding and national renovation programs.

291
00:18:43.079 --> 00:18:52.766
Can you walk me through the mechanism by which that happens and why the absence of a targeting requirement produces such a predictable...

292
00:18:54.267 --> 00:18:55.388
distributional outcome.

293
00:18:55.608 --> 00:18:57.890
And it's interesting because a few episodes ago,

294
00:18:58.130 --> 00:19:01.734
we had Adrian Hill from the Electrification Alliance who said himself,

295
00:19:02.194 --> 00:19:04.636
I could have paid for the work myself,

296
00:19:06.217 --> 00:19:07.518
but I was entitled to grant.

297
00:19:07.579 --> 00:19:09.680
So it's just the way things are done.

298
00:19:11.082 --> 00:19:13.824
And of course he used it because he could,

299
00:19:14.044 --> 00:19:16.726
but why is it still happening,

300
00:19:16.766 --> 00:19:16.907
Anna?

301
00:19:18.668 --> 00:19:20.730
I really don't know.

302
00:19:22.014 --> 00:19:25.296
And I would be so happy if someone would tell me the answer,

303
00:19:25.776 --> 00:19:33.900
but I think it's a really bad way of using public subsidies.

304
00:19:34.600 --> 00:19:37.041
And not like in my work,

305
00:19:37.442 --> 00:19:43.624
I advocate for the improvement of the homes of vulnerable households.

306
00:19:43.684 --> 00:19:45.425
And from my perspective,

307
00:19:45.525 --> 00:19:46.706
it is definitely.

308
00:19:47.461 --> 00:19:55.003
A very problematic issue that there are households that are suffering day after day in their very bad housing condition.

309
00:19:55.443 --> 00:19:56.664
Children get sick.

310
00:19:57.024 --> 00:19:58.164
They don't go to school.

311
00:19:59.844 --> 00:20:04.066
Parents can work less because they also get sick in these circumstances.

312
00:20:04.126 --> 00:20:05.606
And there are so many reasons.

313
00:20:05.686 --> 00:20:16.649
And also there is some science there showing that returns of investments in that specific segment are the largest.

314
00:20:17.049 --> 00:20:18.330
and are really quick.

315
00:20:19.852 --> 00:20:19.972
Yeah,

316
00:20:20.032 --> 00:20:21.793
it's like a low-hanging fruit in a way.

317
00:20:21.913 --> 00:20:22.314
Yes,

318
00:20:22.534 --> 00:20:23.955
it would be like,

319
00:20:24.275 --> 00:20:30.881
it wouldn't only bring benefit for these households that maybe are politically not so important,

320
00:20:31.402 --> 00:20:35.505
but it would also benefit for the common interest,

321
00:20:35.645 --> 00:20:37.367
like reduced health costs,

322
00:20:37.847 --> 00:20:38.788
better economy,

323
00:20:39.429 --> 00:20:44.033
and also these kids would reach them later.

324
00:20:45.377 --> 00:20:46.558
higher achievements,

325
00:20:46.878 --> 00:20:48.159
can get better jobs,

326
00:20:48.339 --> 00:20:50.100
they will pay higher taxes,

327
00:20:50.340 --> 00:20:53.162
and they won't rely on the social security system.

328
00:20:53.442 --> 00:21:00.206
So these are really long-term investments that already generate a return in short term.

329
00:21:01.506 --> 00:21:10.812
And the reason behind the ineffectiveness of these fundings are sometimes very simple,

330
00:21:10.892 --> 00:21:12.993
sometimes more complicated.

331
00:21:13.873 --> 00:21:14.093
Okay,

332
00:21:14.213 --> 00:21:15.594
the simple ones.

333
00:21:16.395 --> 00:21:19.437
It's basically the design of the schemes.

334
00:21:20.438 --> 00:21:21.638
Like in Austria,

335
00:21:22.039 --> 00:21:29.584
they had a subsidy for replacing heating systems targeted to the lowest income households.

336
00:21:29.644 --> 00:21:31.845
And it was a post-financing scheme.

337
00:21:33.426 --> 00:21:37.369
And sometimes I feel that I want to bang my head to the wall.

338
00:21:37.729 --> 00:21:38.069
Like,

339
00:21:38.209 --> 00:21:38.730
why?

340
00:21:40.031 --> 00:21:40.591
Why?

341
00:21:41.492 --> 00:21:43.213
Policymakers believe.

342
00:21:43.617 --> 00:21:52.605
Then vulnerable households have a few thousand euros in their pocket to invest and then reclaim the price of their new heat pump.

343
00:21:52.925 --> 00:21:53.245
Like,

344
00:21:53.886 --> 00:21:54.266
why?

345
00:21:54.867 --> 00:21:56.488
And if they have it in their pocket,

346
00:21:56.588 --> 00:21:57.950
why do they need a subsidy?

347
00:21:59.030 --> 00:22:01.693
So it's just incredibly...

348
00:22:02.794 --> 00:22:03.054
Like,

349
00:22:03.194 --> 00:22:10.821
I think often policymakers still believe that we only need to incentivize these investments.

350
00:22:11.585 --> 00:22:20.948
and a little bit of money so people would do it more willingly than compared to without the support.

351
00:22:21.308 --> 00:22:31.531
But I think now we are already in a place where we see the impact of the climate crisis on our everyday life.

352
00:22:31.691 --> 00:22:38.913
People are more aware and they would anyway do things maybe they need other

353
00:22:39.909 --> 00:22:41.070
like guidances,

354
00:22:41.891 --> 00:22:43.532
technical facilitation,

355
00:22:43.973 --> 00:22:45.654
management in building.

356
00:22:46.114 --> 00:22:56.123
So many other soft tools would facilitate better the energy transition than these generous funding schemes.

357
00:22:57.684 --> 00:22:58.585
Also in Hungary,

358
00:22:58.625 --> 00:23:01.147
we had a renovation scheme,

359
00:23:01.748 --> 00:23:07.653
which was originally quite a good idea because it enabled households not only to work on the...

360
00:23:08.677 --> 00:23:10.318
energy efficiency of the building,

361
00:23:10.458 --> 00:23:15.241
but to any kind of renovation measure that is necessary.

362
00:23:16.302 --> 00:23:17.742
But also there,

363
00:23:17.922 --> 00:23:28.709
it was a post-financing mechanism and it required a few things that usually vulnerable households are not able to demonstrate,

364
00:23:29.149 --> 00:23:35.012
like two years of legal employment history.

365
00:23:36.053 --> 00:23:36.173
Oh,

366
00:23:36.174 --> 00:23:36.393
wow.

367
00:23:37.489 --> 00:23:43.774
having a certain number of children below a certain age,

368
00:23:44.155 --> 00:23:48.358
which is not necessarily overlapping with vulnerability,

369
00:23:48.458 --> 00:23:50.660
the number of kids you have and their age.

370
00:23:50.680 --> 00:23:51.961
Yeah,

371
00:23:52.962 --> 00:23:54.543
it's increasingly patronizing,

372
00:23:54.623 --> 00:23:56.105
this kind of question.

373
00:23:56.905 --> 00:23:57.306
Yes,

374
00:23:57.566 --> 00:24:02.090
and also not having public debt.

375
00:24:03.131 --> 00:24:05.833
And we know that the poorest households...

376
00:24:07.393 --> 00:24:08.294
In Hungary,

377
00:24:08.434 --> 00:24:11.196
have more debt than assets.

378
00:24:11.596 --> 00:24:12.416
So basically,

379
00:24:13.337 --> 00:24:15.439
if you are in the poorest income category,

380
00:24:15.699 --> 00:24:18.501
you most likely have some kind of debt.

381
00:24:18.941 --> 00:24:24.204
So you will not be eligible for this kind of support.

382
00:24:24.945 --> 00:24:30.469
And Habitat for Humanity Hungary made an excellent program together with Erste Bank.

383
00:24:31.809 --> 00:24:37.013
Erste Bank was pre-financing the renovation costs and Habitat put...

384
00:24:37.374 --> 00:24:40.119
next to it the social work to find.

385
00:24:40.820 --> 00:24:45.429
And they keep saying that it was incredibly hard to find among...

386
00:24:46.185 --> 00:24:54.327
The households that they work with and they see day after day which kind of bad housing they are living in.

387
00:24:55.048 --> 00:24:57.888
And they try to feed this household in the program.

388
00:24:58.028 --> 00:25:02.130
And it was extremely hard to find one that would be eligible.

389
00:25:02.710 --> 00:25:05.070
And that's really problematic.

390
00:25:06.291 --> 00:25:07.611
Once they found one,

391
00:25:08.331 --> 00:25:13.533
then they had to put social work hours in it too.

392
00:25:14.321 --> 00:25:23.665
help with the paperwork and also to find a good quality working workforce to deliver the renovation.

393
00:25:24.905 --> 00:25:27.086
And for example,

394
00:25:27.146 --> 00:25:29.887
France already knows that it's not enough to give money,

395
00:25:29.967 --> 00:25:43.573
but they need to have local offices where people go out to their families and they explain the need for renovation and they facilitate the whole application procedure and provide technical advice.

396
00:25:43.917 --> 00:25:45.698
And it's complicated.

397
00:25:46.579 --> 00:25:46.699
Yeah.

398
00:25:47.099 --> 00:25:48.079
It needs time.

399
00:25:48.500 --> 00:25:50.180
But unfortunately,

400
00:25:50.921 --> 00:25:52.522
it is the way to go.

401
00:25:52.642 --> 00:25:53.482
Yeah,

402
00:25:53.562 --> 00:25:53.903
exactly.

403
00:25:53.963 --> 00:25:54.303
Exactly.

404
00:25:54.563 --> 00:25:57.204
Like this kind of offices.

405
00:25:57.284 --> 00:26:00.326
So there is the program called Slimy in English,

406
00:26:00.506 --> 00:26:02.407
or there is a Resoico Habitat,

407
00:26:03.088 --> 00:26:04.969
which also works exactly this way.

408
00:26:05.069 --> 00:26:08.210
But it takes for each of the case,

409
00:26:08.211 --> 00:26:12.693
it takes about two years to set up like the older.

410
00:26:13.173 --> 00:26:15.995
the funding because you need to combine grants,

411
00:26:16.015 --> 00:26:18.677
you need to fill a lot of paperwork.

412
00:26:18.737 --> 00:26:20.378
So it's not something,

413
00:26:20.938 --> 00:26:32.986
it's extremely complicated and it works best for single family housing and not like multi apartment buildings.

414
00:26:33.427 --> 00:26:34.527
But at the same time,

415
00:26:34.727 --> 00:26:38.810
they are also trying to work with low hanging fruits like work,

416
00:26:39.030 --> 00:26:42.553
if they can do some immediate fixing of the house.

417
00:26:43.481 --> 00:26:48.662
Just to start somewhere and to already give people hope and dignity,

418
00:26:48.903 --> 00:26:49.183
right?

419
00:26:49.583 --> 00:26:51.963
Because I think they are like,

420
00:26:53.324 --> 00:26:56.685
for the people who have never visited a household in energy poverty,

421
00:26:56.845 --> 00:26:59.385
or if they have not been energy poor themselves,

422
00:26:59.966 --> 00:27:05.727
they don't realize that the home is for everyone in the Maslow Pyramid.

423
00:27:05.767 --> 00:27:07.548
It's like the place where you need to feel safe.

424
00:27:08.108 --> 00:27:09.288
And if it's shattered,

425
00:27:09.548 --> 00:27:09.988
of course,

426
00:27:09.989 --> 00:27:11.289
your dignity is shattered as well.

427
00:27:12.485 --> 00:27:17.430
You can't trust anything in life if the foundations are not good.

428
00:27:17.490 --> 00:27:26.018
So this feeling of lack of urgency among policymakers also drives me kind of,

429
00:27:26.719 --> 00:27:26.899
yeah,

430
00:27:26.939 --> 00:27:31.583
it drives me mad because we're facing so many challenges at the right time.

431
00:27:32.084 --> 00:27:33.065
And fixing the home,

432
00:27:33.105 --> 00:27:37.269
fixing the energy system would be a way to make our societies way more.

433
00:27:37.973 --> 00:27:44.258
way more cohesive in a way and would be able to make us more resilient towards all the challenges ahead.

434
00:27:44.419 --> 00:27:45.439
And they are there.

435
00:27:45.780 --> 00:27:46.220
Of course,

436
00:27:46.260 --> 00:27:47.401
there are many.

437
00:27:48.002 --> 00:27:49.823
So in talking again about France,

438
00:27:49.883 --> 00:28:00.692
one of the challenges of the program is that every year they have to fight to get their funding in their budget and the funding lines and so on.

439
00:28:00.693 --> 00:28:01.593
So there is this,

440
00:28:02.353 --> 00:28:05.036
the country,

441
00:28:05.396 --> 00:28:06.517
there is always this kind of...

442
00:28:07.205 --> 00:28:24.090
fund and go or stop and go policy is it's also it is also something you've been working on right yes i think predictability should be there because these are long-term projects and also in order to identify

443
00:28:24.550 --> 00:28:34.473
vulnerable households in one of them plan and then carry out the works there is a need for stability and

444
00:28:35.589 --> 00:28:36.930
Going back to France,

445
00:28:37.470 --> 00:28:46.255
it's a good example in the sense that they are providing higher funding rate for lowest income households.

446
00:28:47.256 --> 00:28:49.677
But still in France,

447
00:28:49.857 --> 00:28:53.679
even the highest income group can benefit from subsidies,

448
00:28:54.219 --> 00:28:58.622
repaying part of their costs that they probably wouldn't need.

449
00:28:59.722 --> 00:29:01.163
And on the other hand,

450
00:29:01.503 --> 00:29:04.405
lowest income households still need to contribute.

451
00:29:04.709 --> 00:29:05.950
then 20%

452
00:29:05.951 --> 00:29:06.610
of the work,

453
00:29:06.910 --> 00:29:11.753
which could be if a complex renovation costs 60,000 euros,

454
00:29:12.213 --> 00:29:16.635
it can be fixed at 12,000 euros,

455
00:29:17.236 --> 00:29:21.158
which obviously not in the market of this household.

456
00:29:21.238 --> 00:29:25.960
So even the most progressive large-scale scheme in Europe still...

457
00:29:26.784 --> 00:29:36.990
struggling to incorporate the most vulnerable ones on the expense of still providing support for the richest households.

458
00:29:37.090 --> 00:29:45.835
But at least they realized a few years ago when they had a tax rebate program that

459
00:29:47.656 --> 00:29:51.698
80% of the benefits are going to the richest 20%

460
00:29:51.718 --> 00:29:53.419
and they realized that it's not fair,

461
00:29:53.719 --> 00:29:55.320
so they made a big...

462
00:29:56.180 --> 00:30:00.004
reform in order to have a more progressive scheme.

463
00:30:01.045 --> 00:30:03.607
And getting back to the level of EU funding,

464
00:30:04.588 --> 00:30:07.731
there was this analysis of the Jacques Deler

465
00:30:08.071 --> 00:30:09.953
Institute on Cohesion Policy,

466
00:30:11.714 --> 00:30:13.376
which covers many,

467
00:30:13.416 --> 00:30:14.036
many things,

468
00:30:14.257 --> 00:30:15.798
not only energy efficiency,

469
00:30:17.039 --> 00:30:22.084
and even when it arrives to the poorest regions.

470
00:30:23.256 --> 00:30:31.103
EU funding fails to reach the poorest households because it's always easier to find the middle class.

471
00:30:31.263 --> 00:30:35.226
It's usually the middle class that get employed in EU projects locally.

472
00:30:35.927 --> 00:30:36.347
They get,

473
00:30:37.528 --> 00:30:38.148
for example,

474
00:30:38.168 --> 00:30:38.669
in Hungary,

475
00:30:38.749 --> 00:30:41.611
working in an EU project when you work in the social sector,

476
00:30:41.612 --> 00:30:44.534
it means that you earn maybe double than your colleagues.

477
00:30:45.134 --> 00:30:50.879
So these benefits are going to the more prosperous.

478
00:30:52.240 --> 00:31:07.584
segment of the society in the poor regions and reaching the poor households is often just technically harder also the european funds are really bureaucratic they also have some requirements people

479
00:31:08.164 --> 00:31:21.588
in the poorest households often do not have so they live legally in their homes but maybe the paperwork behind it it's not 100 perfect therefore not eligible for funding that

480
00:31:22.108 --> 00:31:27.410
there they would need some legal and social work to fix those things,

481
00:31:27.490 --> 00:31:29.431
but these are not included in the

482
00:31:30.832 --> 00:31:32.032
EU funding schemes.

483
00:31:33.413 --> 00:31:33.753
Also,

484
00:31:34.473 --> 00:31:34.753
again,

485
00:31:34.813 --> 00:31:36.014
the problem of debt.

486
00:31:36.734 --> 00:31:38.015
If you have debt,

487
00:31:38.135 --> 00:31:39.595
you might not be eligible.

488
00:31:40.116 --> 00:31:45.298
There is no systematic program to tackle debt in order to access,

489
00:31:45.498 --> 00:31:48.219
to facilitate access to funds.

490
00:31:49.179 --> 00:31:50.080
And there are no

491
00:31:50.460 --> 00:31:51.741
specific requirements,

492
00:31:51.841 --> 00:31:52.882
while on the other hand,

493
00:31:52.962 --> 00:31:54.943
with the energy efficiency funding,

494
00:31:55.303 --> 00:31:58.486
they have quite strong indicators on

495
00:31:59.306 --> 00:32:04.009
CO2 reduction or kilowatt hours to reach.

496
00:32:04.169 --> 00:32:14.316
And it's always easier to reach those indicators among middle or upper classes because it's more straightforward.

497
00:32:14.477 --> 00:32:19.180
So there is no motivation to go.

498
00:32:19.440 --> 00:32:22.682
to the more problematic segments of society.

499
00:32:23.662 --> 00:32:29.225
And getting back to the directives that you cited at the beginning,

500
00:32:29.285 --> 00:32:32.026
the EPBD and the Energy Efficiency Directive,

501
00:32:32.406 --> 00:32:33.087
fortunately,

502
00:32:34.147 --> 00:32:43.892
clearly says the need to reach at least a proportional share of all energy savings among vulnerable households to...

503
00:32:45.192 --> 00:32:52.955
prioritize public funding among them and also to target renovation funding in priority to vulnerable households.

504
00:32:53.135 --> 00:33:03.700
But the way these elements are included in the directives are not easily translatable and not easily,

505
00:33:05.500 --> 00:33:10.983
there are no mechanisms behind it that would ensure the implementation.

506
00:33:12.503 --> 00:33:14.124
Maybe the exception is the true

507
00:33:14.844 --> 00:33:19.246
reaching the proportionate share of vulnerable households with energy savings,

508
00:33:19.366 --> 00:33:22.808
it's quite specific because if you reach

509
00:33:23.928 --> 00:33:26.209
100 kilowatt hour of saving,

510
00:33:26.569 --> 00:33:26.829
then

511
00:33:27.489 --> 00:33:32.191
10% should go at least to energy-poor households if you have 10%

512
00:33:32.672 --> 00:33:35.073
energy-poor household in your country.

513
00:33:35.893 --> 00:33:38.094
But currently it's not yet.

514
00:33:38.554 --> 00:33:39.654
It's also quite a new,

515
00:33:40.195 --> 00:33:42.295
a few years old requirement.

516
00:33:43.960 --> 00:33:44.600
While,

517
00:33:44.961 --> 00:33:45.641
for example,

518
00:33:46.021 --> 00:33:47.182
regarding the EPPBD,

519
00:33:47.382 --> 00:33:54.667
there are already infringement procedures related to subsidies for fossil fuel boilers.

520
00:33:55.187 --> 00:33:59.550
There is no infringement procedure for the lack of earmarking of,

521
00:33:59.790 --> 00:34:00.871
or at least targeting,

522
00:34:01.391 --> 00:34:03.392
proportional use of funding.

523
00:34:03.612 --> 00:34:07.315
So it's not a priority.

524
00:34:10.301 --> 00:34:10.621
And yes,

525
00:34:10.681 --> 00:34:15.246
and you also said that in the multi-annual financial framework,

526
00:34:15.346 --> 00:34:17.669
2028-2034,

527
00:34:18.309 --> 00:34:20.812
there is no reflection of these principles either.

528
00:34:21.192 --> 00:34:23.955
And so how do you explain this?

529
00:34:24.015 --> 00:34:24.596
Yeah.

530
00:34:25.948 --> 00:34:26.308
So the

531
00:34:26.969 --> 00:34:29.470
Energy Efficiency Directive says that

532
00:34:30.290 --> 00:34:39.095
EU member states have to make the best possible use of EU funding in order to deliver energy savings to vulnerable households.

533
00:34:40.296 --> 00:34:41.516
But reading the

534
00:34:42.177 --> 00:34:44.258
MFF proposal,

535
00:34:44.638 --> 00:34:55.604
there are some elements that refer to just transition and the need to enable everyone to participate.

536
00:34:56.076 --> 00:34:57.317
in the energy transition.

537
00:34:58.217 --> 00:35:09.824
But this is not specific enough because it's just a specific objective to enable everyone to benefit in the energy transition,

538
00:35:09.884 --> 00:35:23.652
but it's not translated into specific measures that therefore you need to use at least proportionally or each income group should be benefiting from the funds.

539
00:35:23.932 --> 00:35:24.052
Yeah.

540
00:35:24.684 --> 00:35:25.765
At least proportionally,

541
00:35:25.805 --> 00:35:28.007
I would say not necessarily proportionally,

542
00:35:28.047 --> 00:35:31.610
because we don't need to subsidize the richest households from public funding,

543
00:35:31.670 --> 00:35:37.575
because also the EU says very actively that we need to leverage private finance.

544
00:35:38.516 --> 00:35:46.303
And there are also indicators dedicated to the monitoring of the,

545
00:35:46.723 --> 00:35:48.285
like in the monitoring framework.

546
00:35:48.965 --> 00:35:49.786
And there,

547
00:35:50.747 --> 00:35:52.148
once it appears,

548
00:35:52.488 --> 00:35:54.990
related to energy efficiency investment,

549
00:35:55.150 --> 00:36:00.594
and they need to monitor the number of households that are reached by these measures.

550
00:36:01.115 --> 00:36:01.595
But again,

551
00:36:01.675 --> 00:36:08.140
it's not the right tool because in the energy efficiency measures,

552
00:36:08.220 --> 00:36:08.820
they list,

553
00:36:09.381 --> 00:36:10.241
among others,

554
00:36:10.442 --> 00:36:11.162
advice.

555
00:36:11.622 --> 00:36:15.746
So if one member says,

556
00:36:15.747 --> 00:36:16.066
like,

557
00:36:16.486 --> 00:36:16.806
yes,

558
00:36:16.866 --> 00:36:18.468
it won't translate into...

559
00:36:19.108 --> 00:36:22.069
And we can reach a large number of households with advice,

560
00:36:22.669 --> 00:36:32.192
but we would need to monitor the share of energy savings reached among these households because this is what matters.

561
00:36:32.792 --> 00:36:33.452
So therefore,

562
00:36:33.472 --> 00:36:38.773
we were already formulating some amendments because FEAT is also working,

563
00:36:38.813 --> 00:36:39.233
of course,

564
00:36:39.253 --> 00:36:42.874
on homelessness and housing solutions for homeless people.

565
00:36:42.934 --> 00:36:47.596
So we are providing our feedback and proposing amendments.

566
00:36:48.136 --> 00:36:48.556
It's...

567
00:36:49.032 --> 00:36:54.514
When I read the different committees'

568
00:36:54.995 --> 00:37:00.457
contributions to the debate and their suggestions for amendments,

569
00:37:01.177 --> 00:37:03.398
I noted that both the

570
00:37:03.938 --> 00:37:07.660
ITRE committee and the ENBI committee working on industry and environment,

571
00:37:08.900 --> 00:37:17.364
some of the representatives are systematically deleting any reference to just transition and watering down the...

572
00:37:18.420 --> 00:37:29.785
This specific objective that aims to enable everyone to benefit from the transition into some more blurry affordability formulation,

573
00:37:29.905 --> 00:37:34.367
which totally dilutes the aim of inclusivity.

574
00:37:35.847 --> 00:37:43.491
It's really something that you find as anti-egalitarian in Hungarian energy policy as well.

575
00:37:43.571 --> 00:37:45.892
And that's really...

576
00:37:46.596 --> 00:38:04.874
terrifying right because a transition that excludes people completely feeds the forces that are that are trying to dismantle it like it's a say there are really some actors who see just a zero-sum game especially

577
00:38:04.934 --> 00:38:11.200
on the other side of the pond uh the atlantic pond so it's really it's it's really

578
00:38:11.504 --> 00:38:19.126
time to wake up and see that energy policy is citizenship and is democracy and everything is totally linked.

579
00:38:20.026 --> 00:38:29.169
So there are really governance and design gaps that need maybe more aggressive actions also from the EU.

580
00:38:29.809 --> 00:38:33.310
And there have been some recent documents published by the EU,

581
00:38:33.410 --> 00:38:37.011
like the EU Citizens Energy Package and some documents as well,

582
00:38:37.431 --> 00:38:40.192
but they are not mandatory.

583
00:38:40.512 --> 00:38:40.632
so

584
00:38:42.273 --> 00:38:44.815
They can encourage member states to go in a certain direction,

585
00:38:45.015 --> 00:38:51.421
but they will not change the course of things if the states don't want to listen,

586
00:38:51.621 --> 00:38:51.861
right?

587
00:38:52.822 --> 00:38:55.244
I don't want to end on a negative note,

588
00:38:55.284 --> 00:38:57.966
but I want to end with some inspiration from you.

589
00:38:58.066 --> 00:38:58.226
Anna,

590
00:38:58.346 --> 00:39:00.428
you've been working on this well for a lot of time.

591
00:39:00.468 --> 00:39:02.830
You've been gathering so much really,

592
00:39:02.990 --> 00:39:03.230
really,

593
00:39:03.371 --> 00:39:04.672
really interesting evidence.

594
00:39:05.172 --> 00:39:09.576
And I would like you to tell us if there were some...

595
00:39:10.440 --> 00:39:10.700
you know,

596
00:39:10.821 --> 00:39:15.128
design choices that could still be made that would make a difference,

597
00:39:15.328 --> 00:39:17.372
like maybe in the MFF funding,

598
00:39:17.472 --> 00:39:20.837
in the way the social climate fund is rolled out,

599
00:39:21.098 --> 00:39:23.702
in the kind of instruments the EU is developing.

600
00:39:25.503 --> 00:39:25.683
I mean,

601
00:39:25.823 --> 00:39:31.025
that can also be linked to some kind of arguments that is not being made at your level,

602
00:39:31.905 --> 00:39:36.066
something that the policymakers would need to take home,

603
00:39:36.266 --> 00:39:39.967
because that's the right moment to address it,

604
00:39:40.087 --> 00:39:42.008
although they may not know it yet.

605
00:39:43.748 --> 00:39:44.108
Yes,

606
00:39:44.388 --> 00:39:44.508
so

607
00:39:45.929 --> 00:39:54.331
I think it would be nice if the results of the research showcasing that investment And...

608
00:39:54.719 --> 00:39:58.743
in the poorest households in terms of retrofitting,

609
00:39:58.863 --> 00:40:02.286
provides the highest and quickest returns,

610
00:40:02.686 --> 00:40:07.170
would arrive to the policymakers.

611
00:40:07.750 --> 00:40:22.203
And also maybe the private finance sector should play their role in highlighting that until very generous subsidies are provided to you

612
00:40:22.775 --> 00:40:24.216
Without any targeting,

613
00:40:24.976 --> 00:40:34.062
it takes the place of the so much needed private finance because nobody would take up a loan if they can get a free subsidy.

614
00:40:34.982 --> 00:40:41.006
So it's also in the interest of probably the financial institutions.

615
00:40:41.486 --> 00:40:43.507
And also the

616
00:40:44.268 --> 00:40:49.291
Energy Efficiency Financing Coalition of the European Union It may be in that.

617
00:40:50.287 --> 00:40:53.448
great effort of leveraging private finance.

618
00:40:53.488 --> 00:41:01.410
They should also look into how public finance is spent and whether it is truly just leveraging funding,

619
00:41:01.490 --> 00:41:13.674
or it is maybe replacing the market because it takes away the place of private finance.

620
00:41:14.534 --> 00:41:16.214
And in the US,

621
00:41:16.834 --> 00:41:17.095
in the

622
00:41:17.535 --> 00:41:18.455
New York state,

623
00:41:18.735 --> 00:41:25.238
There has already been a period when climate investments were mandatory,

624
00:41:26.138 --> 00:41:33.161
partially targeted to underserved communities with a very detailed design.

625
00:41:33.941 --> 00:41:40.744
And it was mandatory so that the benefits of climate measures,

626
00:41:41.505 --> 00:41:42.425
35%

627
00:41:42.885 --> 00:41:47.087
of the benefits should go to underserved communities.

628
00:41:47.675 --> 00:41:58.184
And it created a various range of programs from district heating installations to solar panels to training programs for workers,

629
00:41:58.524 --> 00:42:07.291
maybe installing those solar panels in order to distribute the benefits in a socially meaningful way.

630
00:42:08.132 --> 00:42:09.293
And if in the US,

631
00:42:09.393 --> 00:42:15.858
which is way more capitalistic and free market friendly.

632
00:42:16.939 --> 00:42:19.140
on paper than Europe.

633
00:42:19.440 --> 00:42:21.361
If they could do it,

634
00:42:21.941 --> 00:42:22.422
I think

635
00:42:22.882 --> 00:42:25.603
Europe should also be able to do it.

636
00:42:26.683 --> 00:42:28.344
But in the context of...

637
00:42:28.345 --> 00:42:29.365
So you can make it there,

638
00:42:29.425 --> 00:42:30.545
you can make it anywhere.

639
00:42:31.606 --> 00:42:32.006
Yes,

640
00:42:32.686 --> 00:42:42.891
but in the context of the current defence and competitiveness and simplification agenda.

641
00:42:44.215 --> 00:42:45.055
On the other hand,

642
00:42:45.135 --> 00:42:54.159
it's really difficult to advocate for earmarking because it's an additional bureaucratic burden.

643
00:42:54.980 --> 00:42:57.321
But unfortunately,

644
00:42:58.161 --> 00:43:04.844
I don't see any other way to ensure that funding is arriving where it should arrive.

645
00:43:05.144 --> 00:43:08.946
So it's difficult to get to that point.

646
00:43:10.327 --> 00:43:10.847
Yeah,

647
00:43:10.848 --> 00:43:11.127
okay.

648
00:43:11.407 --> 00:43:15.711
That's an extremely interesting and sobering conversation,

649
00:43:15.771 --> 00:43:15.932
Anna.

650
00:43:16.132 --> 00:43:17.753
Thank you for taking the time.

651
00:43:18.034 --> 00:43:18.354
And

652
00:43:19.075 --> 00:43:21.878
I will definitely put some resources in the show notes.

653
00:43:22.138 --> 00:43:23.099
And thank you.

654
00:43:23.539 --> 00:43:24.140
Thank you so much.

655
00:43:24.240 --> 00:43:24.861
See you next time.

656
00:43:24.881 --> 00:43:25.281
Thank you.

657
00:43:25.641 --> 00:43:26.082
Thank you.

658
00:43:26.803 --> 00:43:28.544
Energetic explores the people,

659
00:43:28.664 --> 00:43:33.269
policies and institutions shaping Europe's and the world's energy transition.

660
00:43:33.950 --> 00:43:34.971
I am Marine Cornelis.

661
00:43:35.211 --> 00:43:37.075
If you found this conversation valuable,

662
00:43:37.135 --> 00:43:39.520
you can share it with colleagues working on housing,

663
00:43:39.600 --> 00:43:41.124
governance and consumer protection.

664
00:43:41.705 --> 00:43:44.731
You will find references and further reading in the show notes.

665
00:43:45.112 --> 00:43:45.854
Until next time.

